SCOTUS Highlights and Insights From the Kaestner Oral Arguments

The United States Supreme Court Hears Oral Arguments for North Carolina v. Kaestner

On April 17, 2019, the United States Supreme Court heard the oral arguments in perhaps the most significant trust case in 100 years: North Carolina Department Of Revenue, Petitioner, V. The Kimberley Rice Kaestner 1992 Family Trust, Respondent. 

The crux of the Kaestner case is whether the state of North Carolina should be able to constitutionally tax trusts where the only connection to the state is that the beneficiary is a resident.

In the state of North Carolina, the taxpayer won throughout the entire court system, but North Carolina appealed successfully to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Matthew W. Sawchak, North Carolina Solicitor General, argued on behalf of the Petitioner and David A. O’Neil, Esq., of Debevoise & Plimpton LLP  on behalf of the Respondent.

In the hour-long arguments, the Justices actively participated, frequently interrupting the counsels. Overall, based on our initial analysis of the transcript, the line of questioning from the majority of the Justices seemed to be slightly more sympathetic to the Respondent. However, there were several times the Justices were challenging the Respondent’s arguments.

Continue reading SCOTUS Highlights and Insights From the Kaestner Oral Arguments

Want us to give you a call?

Let our experienced team help you with your trust needs

By providing my phone number to “Alliance Trust Company, LLC”, I agree and acknowledge that “Alliance Trust Company, LLC” may send text messages to my wireless phone number for any purpose. Message and data rates may apply. We will only send one SMS as a reply to you, and you will be able to opt out by replying “STOP”. For more information on how your data will be handled please visit https://alliancetrustcompany.com/privacy-policy